December 17 2018 / Rating: 2.9 / Views: 520

How to do an article review - How To Complete A Good Academic Article Review- Writing Guide

Customize Your Literature Review to Your Field and the Specific Journal Depending on the field you are in and the specific journal you target, the literature review will be longer and more detailed, as in some of the social sciences that highly value theory, or short and to the point, as in many medical and health-focused journals that highly value applications of research to practice.

The thread of the author s argument becomes lost in an overuse of empirical data. Do capture the main points of each section, as space allows. The body paragraphs are often the toughest part it s in this part of a review where the student really examines every part of the article from the methods used to the outcome. Article Review Writing an article review isn t rocket science or brain surgery.

Locate the topic sentences and highlight the main points as you read. The tables figures do little to help greatly help the reader. I also consider whether the article contains a good Introduction and description of the state of the art, as that indirectly shows whether the authors have a good knowledge of the field. Common Mistakes Absence of emphasis or intention. Contact your personal writer any time to track the progress or to add comments which you have forgotten. Don t take my word for it, but being a scientist is about being a skeptic, says Tim van der Zee in this post. Start your review by referring to the title and author of the article, the title of the journal, and the year of publication in the first paragraph. Egan analysis of clinical research or refereed or illegal essay, when writing poetry and views. I m a nurse, making an expand course about incontinence. For these, you would probably switch to the next option.

Research what people are currently discussing in the society. The longest I ve written was about five pages, and the shortest was about 10 lines.

Depending on how much time I have, I sometimes also end with a section of minor comments. Part 1 Quiz What should you include in an article review?

Generally, this means you need to provide a well-reasoned answer to the question or a well justified solution to a problem. The writer then introduces the author of the article and where the information is available, the credentials of the author and some of their other works. Such elements of the content as critical facts and statistics are crucial for your article review.

This allows you to gain a more objective perspective on your ideas. When the brief is to write one of these pieces, the instructor, supervisor, or editor must clarify exactly what they would like to read when it is finished and submitted. For example The article, Condom use will increase the spread of AIDS, was written by Anthony Zimmerman, a Catholic priest. Major comments may include suggesting a missing control that could make or break the authors conclusions or an important experiment that would help the story, though I try not to recommend extremely difficult experiments that would be beyond the scope of the paper or take forever. This helps me to distinguish between major and minor issues and also to group them thematically as I draft my review. Take a look at the goals of the research and the thesis statement.

As a group of professional writers, we know how to write all kinds of assignments. It was really helpful, as I didn t understand how to write review articles at school. br SUMMARY br Present a summary of the key points along with a limited number of examples. On the other hand, the author wisely suggests proposes that.

Special plagiarism check system that we are using checks the text on a high level which won t let a writer copy paste any phrase. Some are not long enough to do all of the points listed above. The first is by using brackets at the end of a sentence for exmample, Evidence shows that strategic frameworks are a necessity in successful business management Smith Gerald 1998.

Sometimes I will say in a review something like, I disagree with the authors about this but it is scientifically valid and an appropriate use of journal space for them to make this argument. Decide between a declarative title, descriptive title, or interrogative title. If a reviewer is up to the job of producing a well-organized and methodical review, which flows well and provides a service to the readership, then it should be possible to be objective in reviewing one s own relevant findings. Locate the topic sentences and highlight the main points as you read.

Respond only to the author s research do not provide any new research.

Review the summary outline to eliminate unnecessary items.

The main two elements of article review are a theoretical and objective discussion. When you read the first time, just read for the big picture that is, look for the overall argument and point the article is making.

You can also briefly explain the author s purpose intentions throughout the text and you may briefly describe how the text is organised. Then, throughout, if what I am reading is only partly I do not spend a lot of energy trying to make sense of it, but in my review I will relay the ambiguities to the author. If it is a scientific review article, it uses database searches to portray the research.

However, it s important that the articles you are going to use are connected to your study.

For example, the article might have incorrectly reported the facts of a popular study.

An article of yours may have been cited in the manuscript to be reviewed. Determine how the article you are reviewing is similar and different from other texts you ve read on the subject.

Writing a good review requires expertise in the field, an intimate knowledge of research methods, a critical mind, the ability to give fair and constructive feedback, and sensitivity to the feelings of authors on the receiving end.

Article review writing process The first part of the article review essay is the title, which informs the readers what the essay is about.

The choice between different review types will have to be made on a case-by-case basis, depending not just on the nature of the material found and the preferences of the target journal s, but also on the time available to write the review and the number of coauthors. Performing your own critical analysis of an article allows you to consider its value to you and to your workplace.

How to Write a Journal Article Review Example According to the summary of the recent academic surveys held by Harvard and Yale, 80 of all authors work better if they have an example of necessary content in front of them.

Really interesting in helping people who engage in this business. This is because the expectations may be different at other institutions. A quality evaluation must be communicated in sufficient detail to support the reviewer s recommendation to the Editor. I try to be constructive by suggesting ways to improve the problematic aspects, if that is possible, and also try to hit a calm and friendly but also neutral and objective tone. Eliminate all notes that do not relate to your thesis.

Do you know of any references that authors might want to refer to and discuss? Further resources You may also be interested in our page on criticality, which covers criticality in general, and includes more critical reading questions.

Some of these citations will simply describe the prevalence or incidence of a problem or possibly the size of the population affected e.

Put aside a considerable period of time to include the interviewing and researching. I would really encourage other scientists to take up peer-review opportunities whenever possible.

Your article review should definitely respond to the author s ideas with your own thoughtful reasoning.

If you include unique or specialist phrases from the text, use quotation marks. Example If you open up, you can search for review articles on the drug Paxil by putting Paxil in the search bar, then clicking the SEARCH button.

This explanation has a few weaknesses that other researchers have pointed out see Author, Year Author, Year. You may have submitted an article to the journal yourself. Does the author answer the questions he she sets out to answer? Reviewers are not asked to guarantee that the information in the article is correct. In a paragraph, summarize the main points of the article, as well as your opinions about its significance, accuracy, and clarity. Maier HR 2013 What constitutes a good literature review and why does its quality matter? Outside of the education system, experts often review the work of their peers for clarity, originality, and contribution to the discipline of study. One gets to know super fresh research firsthand and gain insight into other authors argument structure.

Sutherland WJ, Fleishman E, Mascia MB, Pretty J, Rudd MA 2011 Methods for identifying research priorities and emerging issues in science and policy. At some point in your scholarly career, you likely will get asked to review an article for a journal. A brief letter addressed to the editor not for the author s eyes with a specific

How to Write a Journal Article Review APA Style The Pen and The Pad How to Write a Journal Article Review APA Style by A.

What were the strengths and weaknesses of the study?

Here are some major areas of criticism to consider Is the article After putting the article in your own words, decide which parts of the article you want to discuss in your review.

Make sure you have identified and discussed the 3-4 key issues in the article.

Tags: #do an article, #how to

New essay: